Ehrlich v. United States
File — Folder: 1
Identifier: Folder 1
No. 16,712; 252 F.2d 772 (1958)
Of three points raised on appeal, Judge Wisdom and Chief Judge Hutcheson tentatively agreed to reverse on one, Judge Wisdom to write the majority opinion, Judge Tuttle to dissent. Judge Wisdom reconsidered; Chief Judge Hutcheson suggested that he, rather than Judge Wisdom, should write the opinion. Judge Wisdom then circulated a draft to reverse on two of the three issues, and Chief Judge Hutcheson responded by dissenting in part. As the opinion is reported, Judge Wisdom wrote for a majority of the court on two issues, Chief Judge Hutcheson on the third.
Includes original opinion of Judge Wisdom; TL of Judge Wisdom on his opinion as originally written; TLS of Chief Judge Hutcheson on the proposed opinion of Judge Wisdom; TLS of Chief Judge Hutcheson on the opinion as reported and the result finally reached in the case; TL of Judge Cameron on the opinion as reported, and on his own opinions, dissenting, in United States General Box Co., 224 F.2d 7 (1955), and Daniel v. United States, 234 F.2d 102 (1956); and, TLS of Judge Brown on the opinion as reported.
See also 3:9.
Of three points raised on appeal, Judge Wisdom and Chief Judge Hutcheson tentatively agreed to reverse on one, Judge Wisdom to write the majority opinion, Judge Tuttle to dissent. Judge Wisdom reconsidered; Chief Judge Hutcheson suggested that he, rather than Judge Wisdom, should write the opinion. Judge Wisdom then circulated a draft to reverse on two of the three issues, and Chief Judge Hutcheson responded by dissenting in part. As the opinion is reported, Judge Wisdom wrote for a majority of the court on two issues, Chief Judge Hutcheson on the third.
Includes original opinion of Judge Wisdom; TL of Judge Wisdom on his opinion as originally written; TLS of Chief Judge Hutcheson on the proposed opinion of Judge Wisdom; TLS of Chief Judge Hutcheson on the opinion as reported and the result finally reached in the case; TL of Judge Cameron on the opinion as reported, and on his own opinions, dissenting, in United States General Box Co., 224 F.2d 7 (1955), and Daniel v. United States, 234 F.2d 102 (1956); and, TLS of Judge Brown on the opinion as reported.
See also 3:9.
Dates
- Created: 1957-1958
Extent
From the Collection: 0.00 Linear Feet
Creator
- From the Collection: Wisdom, John Minor (Person)
Repository Details
Part of the Tulane Law School Repository
Contact:
6239 Freret St
New Orleans LA 70118 US
6239 Freret St
New Orleans LA 70118 US