Memoranda, cases argued March 13-16, 1961 -- New Orleans, Louisiana -- before Judges Rives, Brown, and Wisdom, 1961

File — Folder: 12

Identifier: Folder 12

Staff Only

Includes memoranda on:

Chapman v. United States No. 18,685; 289 F.2d 539, cert. den. 368 U.S. 860 (1961)

Includes TLS of Judge Rives on his proposed opinion.

Collins v. United States No. 18,668; 289 F.2d 129 (1961)

The judges had tentatively agreed to affirm, but Judge Rives, upon further reflection, came to favor reversal, and circulated a proposed opinion to that effect.

Includes TLS of Judge Rives on his proposed opinion as opposed to the tentative conference agreement of the judges.

Delgado v. Malula, The No. 18,470; 291 F.2d 420 (1961)

Includes TLS of Judge Brown on the merits and his proposed opinions in Delgado and Vega v. The Malula, 291 F.2d 415 (1961); and , TLS of Judge Rives on the two opinions of Judge Brown.

Jimenez v. Aristeguieta No. 18,408; 290 F.2d 106 (1961)

Includes TL of Judge Brown on the merits and his proposed specially concurring opinion; and , TL of Judge Wisdom on the Brown opinion, on Hall v. C.I.R., 294 F.2d 82 (1961), referring to Herman v. United States 289 F.2d 362 (1961) and to Judge Mathes (S.D. Cal.)

See also 656:3.

June T., Inc. v. King No. 18,630; 290 F.2d 404 (1961)

Includes TLS of Judge Brown on his proposed opinion.

Sax v. Sax No. 18,453; 294 F.2d 133 (1961)

Judge Wisdom, at the same timre concurring, suggested certain changes in the opinion which Judge Brown declined to make.

Includes TLS (2) of Judge Brown and TLS of Judge Wisdom on the merits and the opinion of Judge Brown.

Truck Drivers & Helpers Loca Union NO. 728 v. Empire State Express, Inc. No. 13,582; 293 F.2d 414, cert. den. 368 U.S. 931 (1961)

Judge Brown was of the view that the case should have been remanded in lieu of rendition, but nonetheless concurred in the majority opinion.

The opinion as proposed by Judge Rives was first revised to meet objections of Judge Brown, and, references in the opinion to the proceedings below as conducted by Judge Bootle were then 'toned down' at the suggestion of Judge Wisdom.

Includes TLS of Judge Brown on the merits and the opinion as proposed by Judge Rives; TLS of Judge Rives on revision of his opinion in response to the objections of Judge Brown; TL of Judge Wisdom on further revision of the opinion as warranted; and, TLS of Judge Rives on further revision of the opinion as suggested by Judge Wisdom

Vega v. Malula, The No. 13,469; 291 F.2d 415 (1961)

See Delgado, above.