Folder 1

Scope and Contents No. 16,479; 252 F.2d 49 (1958)Initially the judges in this case were unanimously in favor of reversal. Judge Wisdom reconsidered, then wrote and circulated an opinion for affirmance. Chief Judge Hutcheson and Judge Rives were not convinced and persuaded Judge Wisdom to modify his opinion, making the reversal unanimous.Includes Judge Wisdom's proposed opinion to affirm; TL (4) of Judge Wisdom, TLS (2) of Judge Rives, and TL and TLS of Chief Judge Hutcheson on the merits...