Folder 2

Scope and Contents Winters v. Cook No. 71-3323; 489 F.2d 174 (1973), rev'g 466 F.2d 1393 (1972) Judge Clark proposed a per curiam affirmance to the judges on the en banc court. When Judges Rives and Godbold each responded with dissenting opinions, the majority opinion was amended to adopt the panel dissent of Judge Clark. This induced Judge Rives to circulate, first to Judges Brown, Wisdom, Goldberg, and Godbold, and after having revised it, to the remaining judges, a 'further dissenting opinion'. Judge Wisdom...